Analyzed statements
DEBATE LULA E BOLSONARO COMPLETO: Lula e Bolsonaro participam do 1º debate presidencial do 2º turno
236 classified statements · 2 politicians · October 17, 2022 · 164 min
Statements by Luis Inacio Lula da Silva, Jair Messias Bolsonaro. 236 excerpts classified by topic and stance. Topics: Public Budget, State public debt, Social Policy, Fiscal Reform.
Speakers
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva103- JBJair Messias Bolsonaro84
Classified statements
Excerpts classified by topic and stance. This is not the full transcript of the video.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
0:45
About: reduce spending in the 4% of the federal budget under presidential control
In advanced countries, in the more civilized countries, in budgetary terms, half of the budget is controlled in this constitutional way and half is commanded by the president. Here in Brazil, 96% of the money goes straight to its destination, without the president's hand; four remain in the hands of the President of the Republic. And to carry out new projects, new ideas, new programs, you have to take from a project, you have to take from an idea, you have to take from a program. I want to know, to carry out the projects and programs that you gentlemen propose in the campaign, where will you cut?
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence moderator asks about cutting resources from the 4% of the budget.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
1:16
About: reduce spending in the 4% of the federal budget under presidential control
From the 4% that you command or will you propose constitutional changes to touch the other 96%?
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence reiterates the option of cutting from the 4% of funds controlled by the president.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
1:51
About: renegotiate precatórios installments to enable social programs
Let me be clear, when we created Auxílio Brasil at the end of last year, we renegotiated the installment payment of precatórios.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence claims government action: 'nós renegociamos o parcelamento dos precatórios'.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
1:59
About: implement more measures to support families
And we then created an emergency aid of R$ 400.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence states the creation of the R$400 emergency aid in a claiming tone ('criamos').
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
2:34
About: adopt fiscal responsibility in government
This remaining 4% of the budget is very small. But we do everything, as we will do, as we have done in the past, within fiscal responsibility.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence defends that the actions are carried out 'dentro da responsabilidade fiscal'.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
2:54
About: adopt fiscal responsibility in government
with the market, as well as fluctuations in the dollar. So we do everything with responsibility.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence reiterates that the government acts within fiscal responsibility to avoid losing control.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
3:07
About: propose an emergency aid of R$600
To say that the Workers' Party had proposed, before voting, the R$600,000 emergency aid.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence states that PT had proposed R$600 aid and is not proposing a new action now.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
3:30
About: plan and execute public investments to expand investment capacity
In fact, what did we do? We proved to Brazilian society that it is possible to have investment capacity when we plan and when we, you know, put the money in the right place.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence claims that 'nós provamos ... ter capacidade de investimento quando planeja'.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
3:43
About: increase investment in public infrastructure
When we did the PAC in February 2007,
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence claims execution of the PAC and investments in public works during their government.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
3:47
About: increase investment in public infrastructure
We invested practically one trillion and four billion reais during the whole PAC process to build 13,000 works that were delivered and another 13,000 that remained to be finished, some of which are finishing now.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence lists PAC investments and projects as concrete government action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
4:02
About: approve a fiscal reform
The important point is that, if you know how to work, plan, you will have the money to do things and, at the same time, we are sure that Congress will approve a tax reform so that we can, with the tax reform, tax less.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence states that Congress will approve tax reform 'para que a gente possa... taxar menos'.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
4:18
About: exempt incomes up to R$5.000 from income tax and tax the richest more
The poorest, the workers, that's why we propose an exemption up to 5,000 reais of non-payment of income tax and to tax the richer, who many times do not pay on profit, on selling. Then we will have money to carry out the policies we did.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence explicitly proposes exemption up to R$5.000 and charging the rich more.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
5:41
About: expand the reach of public policies to vulnerable populations
for the judiciary to fulfill its role. But above all, it is necessary to bring the poorest people back to citizenship.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence defends 'trazer o povo mais pobre à cidadania outra vez' as a political goal.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
5:48
About: expand the reach of public policies to vulnerable populations
When I governed from 2003 to 2010, we implemented the largest social inclusion policy that this country's history has known. We created 22 million jobs, we raised the minimum wage, we were the government that built the most universities and technical schools in this country.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence claims their record of inclusion and job creation as a model proposal.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
9:56
About: grant amnesty of up to 99% of FIES debts
allowed up to 99% amnesty of that youth's debt. We took those kids out of default.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence claims government action: 'permitimos a anistia de até 99% da dívida'.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
10:24
About: expand access to vocational education and higher education
Because we created 18 new universities, 178 campuses, in addition to ProUni and Fies. With Fies, a person didn't have to pay while studying.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence claims the creation of universities, ProUni and FIES as government policy.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
10:52
About: buy vaccines in a timely manner during the pandemic
Why was there such a delay in buying vaccines? Don't you feel responsible? Do you not carry on your shoulders some of the suffering of Brazilians for being responsible for at least 400,000 deaths in this country?
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence directly demands 'Por que houve tanta demora para se comprar vacina?' and holds them responsible for the delay.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
11:27
About: acquire vaccines at scale to immunize the population
We bought more than 500 million doses of vaccine.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence states 'Nós compramos mais de 500 milhões de doses', claiming government action.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
11:32
About: encourage vaccination (symbolic campaign act)
And everyone who wanted a vaccine got vaccinated.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence reports as fact that 'todos aqueles que quiseram tomar vacina, tomaram'.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
11:35
About: implement a broad vaccination campaign to immunize the population rapidly
And Brazil was one of the countries that vaccinated the most in the world and in the fastest time. So, sir, inform yourself.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence states a comparative fact: 'o Brasil foi um dos países que mais vacinou' without proposing new action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
12:02
About: buy vaccines in a timely manner during the pandemic
And the concrete fact is that your negligence caused 680 people to die, when more than half could have been saved.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence attributes negligence that 'fez com que 680 pessoas morressem', demanding timely purchases.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
12:58
About: follow scientific evidence and not promote ineffective treatments
You promoted a medicine that science denied the whole time. You didn't respect Butantan, you didn't respect Fiocruz, which are laboratories of excellence in this country, which could have helped.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence criticizes promotion of ineffective medicine and defends science as a guide.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
13:10
About: respect and coordinate with national institutes (Butantan, Fiocruz) in the pandemic response
If you had had humility, you could have solved part of the problem,
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence criticizes that Butantan and Fiocruz were not respected, defending their involvement.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
13:30
About: implement public health measures to control the Covid-19 pandemic
Mr. Lula, what I was against was Mr. Mandetta's protocol.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence explicitly states 'o que eu fui contra foi o protocolo do senhor Mandetta'.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
13:53
About: allow medical autonomy to prescribe off-label treatments
whether or not it had scientific proof, which was something unprecedented throughout the world.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence supports treatment 'tendo ou não comprovação científica' and medical autonomy.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
14:01
About: allow medical autonomy to prescribe off-label treatments
The so-called off-label prescription. That's what was castrated in Brazil.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence states that the 'receita off-label ... foi castrada', defending the practice.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
15:39
About: involve experts in public health management
The truth, Bolsonaro, the truth is that you appointed a Minister of Health who didn't understand; the only one who seemed to understand a bit was Mandetta, whom you removed immediately, then you appointed another who didn't understand, until you reached Pazuello.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence criticizes appointments ('Pazuello... não entendia nada de saúde') and defends technical competence.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
16:16
About: investigate allegations of corruption in vaccine purchases by the Attorney General's Office
And obviously the people expect that one day the Attorney General's Office will investigate to find out the truth or not.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence asks that the PGR investigate allegations related to vaccine purchases.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
17:17
About: subject public contracts to competitive bidding
The biggest theft. And who pays the bill? The federal government. So we did not accept the continuation of the stealing.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence opposes purchases 'sem certificação da Anvisa' and without bidding, to avoid corruption.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
17:50
About: buy vaccines in a timely manner during the pandemic
the deaths of 400 people that could have been avoided if the vaccine had been bought at the right time, at the correct time.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence says deaths could have been avoided 'se tivesse comprado a vacina no tempo certo'.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
17:58
About: buy vaccines in a timely manner during the pandemic
Science says that every day. You received a vaccine proposal very early and did not want to buy because you didn't believe it.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence blames failure on refusing to buy vaccines early: 'recebeu proposta muito cedo e não quis comprar'.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
19:05
About: downplay the severity of Covid in public communication
Brazil has a hot climate, don't be afraid of Covid.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence says 'não tenha medo da Covid', publicly downplaying the risk.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
19:09
About: minimize Covid risks for healthy people in public communication
And the one who talked about a little flu was there. What I always said, that healthy people...
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence uses the term 'gripezinha' to describe the risk to healthy people.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
19:14
About: minimize Covid risks for healthy people in public communication
didn't have to fear Covid. You couldn't abuse it, obviously.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence states that healthy people 'não tinham que temer' Covid.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
19:22
About: recommend protective measures for people with reduced mobility against Covid
and those who truly had mobility issues to be careful.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence advises people with mobility to take care, advocating targeted protection.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
19:26
About: declare a state of emergency in situations of public health calamity
It was the role of the government, which was perhaps the first in the world, to declare a state of emergency, which was ignored.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence claims that 'decretou estado de emergência' as a government action.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
19:34
About: cancel or restrict public events during a pandemic
by those who wanted Carnival at any cost. So, Mr. Lula.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence criticizes those who wanted Carnival 'a qualquer preço', supporting event restrictions.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
19:53
About: implement and prioritize a national COVID vaccination campaign
You are the king of fake news, you are the king of the stupidity of lying to Brazilian society. And you lied about the vaccine all the time, neglected the vaccine, and Brazil today carries the stigma of being the country with the most deaths from Covid. It's lamentable.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence accuses vaccine negligence and defends the national vaccination campaign.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
20:27
About: reduce Covid deaths among children
You say no child died, two thousand children died of Covid.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence reports the number of child deaths from Covid without proposing explicit action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
20:35
About: encourage vaccination (symbolic campaign act)
It was necessary to keep lying about Covid, it was necessary to keep discrediting it. And I know what the people who lost someone dear think. I myself lost a mother-in-law, you know, because of Covid.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence criticizes 'continuar mentindo' and advocates acknowledgment and vaccination.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
22:18
About: acquire COVID vaccines for the population
I repeat, we bought 500 million doses of vaccine.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims the purchase of '500 milhões de doses' as a government action.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
22:28
About: implement a large-scale COVID vaccination campaign
Brazil was an example to the world with respect to vaccination.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence states that 'o Brasil foi um exemplo' in vaccination, defending the program.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
22:32
About: acquire and start early COVID vaccination in the country
Less than a month after the first dose was administered in the world, Brazil began to administer it. And all the vaccines were purchased by the federal government. We are proud of that work.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims an early start to vaccination and federal purchase of vaccines.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
22:43
About: implement a large-scale COVID vaccination campaign
We saved millions of lives. If it had been with someone from your government, someone from the Northeast Consortium, you would have stolen everything.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence attributes lives saved to the government's vaccination campaign.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
23:09
About: preserve Brazil's capacity for mass vaccination
Because Brazil is a country that has expertise in vaccination.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence claims 'expertise em vacinação' without detailing a specific proposal.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
23:12
About: preserve and value the public vaccination system
Besides, Brazil is an example to the world in vaccination.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence says that 'Brasil é exemplo' in vaccination in a descriptive way.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
23:15
About: prioritize measures to protect lives during health crises
Brazil faltered when it had a president who did not take care, who was not responsible.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence criticizes presidential negligence and demands a responsible stance.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
23:19
About: prioritize measures to protect lives during health crises
Who joked around and did not believe in the vaccine.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence says the opponent 'brincava' and 'não acreditava na vacina', arguing for responsibility.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
23:30
About: implement public health measures to control the Covid-19 pandemic
at least 400 thousand people who died due to negligence.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence attributes 400,000 deaths to 'negligenciamento', advocating effective policies.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
23:46
About: reduce homicides in the country
59 police officers were executed here in the state of São Paulo.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence reports that '59 policiais foram executados' without proposing immediate action.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
23:58
About: transfer faction leaders to maximum-security prisons
He could no longer stay here commanding the crime.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence justifies the transfer to prevent them from directing crime.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
24:04
About: investigate and punish agreements between authorities and criminal organizations
From all indications, he made a deal with Marcola and with your Alckmin, who was governor of São Paulo at that time. I repeat.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence accuses an agreement between government officials and Marcola, implicitly calling for an investigation.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
24:10
About: reduce murders of police officers and violence against security agents
In 2006, 59 police officers murdered in São Paulo.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence reports the number of police officers killed without proposing a concrete measure in his speech.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
24:19
About: transfer faction leaders to federal prisons under a special regime
together with Minister Sérgio Moro, so that we then would remove a 'cola'.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims a joint action with the minister to transfer a criminal leader.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
24:27
About: confine criminal leaders in solitary confinement in federal prisons
Federal (prison), under a very special regime, without any communication with the outside world.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence advocates for a federal prison under a special regime without external communication.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
24:35
About: transfer crime leaders to federal maximum-security prisons
the number of violent deaths in our country. Because if I had not transferred Marcola in 2006, since there was a request from the State MP to do so? It was affection, friendship.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence attributes the drop in violent deaths to the transfer of criminal leaders.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
24:46
About: investigate agreements between government officials and criminal organizations
or a big deal at that time, together with your vice.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence suggests there was a 'grande acordo' between rulers and criminals, calling for investigation.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
25:01
About: investigate and hold accountable links between politicians and militias
Whoever has ties with the militiaman who is organized, he knows it's not me and he knows who does.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence says the opponent has ties to militias, implicitly calling for investigation.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
25:07
About: investigate and punish those responsible for the assassination of Marielle Franco
He even knows the culpability that it was organized crime that killed Marielle in the
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence attributes blame to organized crime and points to the need for holding them accountable.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
25:18
About: build and use maximum-security prisons for criminal leaders
We would have transferred because I was the one who created maximum-security prisons. Five prisons, five.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims to have made five arrests and established maximum-security prisons during his government.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
26:19
About: investigate links between politicians and criminal organizations
So true is your affinity with traffickers and criminals that you preside over Brazil.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence accuses the opponent of ties with traffickers, suggesting an inquiry.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
26:48
About: investigate and punish favoritism toward allies in the prison system
This is the truth: to build a prison and leave your friends
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence accuses him of leaving friends free and demands accountability for favoritism.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
27:17
About: investigate links between politicians and militias
Because Bolsonaro is friends with the militias, you go carefully.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence states the opponent is an 'amigo dos milicianos', implicitly calling for investigation.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
28:25
About: reduce the price of gasoline
10% of the money that you put into this thing. It's just for me to say something, you go there and do it. I said that the price of gasoline would go down. He reduced it, it'll go up again.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence states he would reduce the price of gasoline as an electoral proposal.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
28:55
About: implement the São Francisco River transposition to bring water to the Northeast
that the one who carried out the São Francisco transposition was the man speaking to you, because I am from the Northeast; I have experienced carrying a bucket of water and a can of water on my head.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims authorship of the transposition and personal experience as someone from the Northeast.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
29:24
About: ensure access to water for the Northeast
You denied water to your northeastern brothers.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence says water was denied to people in the Northeast and demands it be prioritized.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
29:38
About: complete ongoing state public works
In fact, it was a project that led nowhere.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence labels the project as halted and justifies its immediate resumption and completion.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
29:42
About: combat corruption in refining projects and public investments
We took over a project that had been stalled for almost 10 years. A project stalled for almost 10 years is worse than starting one. You did embezzle, yes, a lot of money went to corruption.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence accuses diversion of resources in the project and calls for accountability.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
29:55
About: implement transposition works and bring water to the Northeast
You denied water to the Northeastern people. I brought water with the transposition and with Rogério Marinho. And even more.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims to have brought water to the Northeast through the transposition and federal policies.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
30:14
About: prioritize waterworks and water supply in the Northeast
the water of the São Francisco. So you really mistreated them. It should have been your total priority.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence demands that bringing water to the Northeast should be 'prioridade número um'.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
30:41
About: implement and complete the São Francisco River transposition
Because I completed 88% of the São Francisco works.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims to have completed 88% of the transposition works as a merit of his government.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
30:54
About: invest in paving and rehabilitation of state roads and public transport
He even tells me he did BR-163, all built by the PT government, with more than 80% of the works done.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence claims his government executed highways and other works.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
31:17
About: complete ongoing state public works
to continue now to speak, folks, I want to say that this work here is President Lula's, he was more competent than I was, he did the project, you know? I'm only going to give a little push here to finish that small piece that's missing.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence argues that projects should be sensibly completed between administrations.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
32:26
About: complete ongoing state public works
When we appointed Tarcísio, in six months, with
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence attributes the quick completion of BR-163 to his minister's management and coordinated action.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
32:35
About: investigate embezzlement in public infrastructure works
Fourteen years and those 50 kilometers were forgotten. In other words, don't talk about infrastructure or water for the Northeast without having the minimum knowledge. You should remember very well, it's about the diverted funds.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence accuses money being diverted in projects and demands an investigation.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
33:08
About: implement a broad national infrastructure policy
we carried out the largest infrastructure policy this country has ever known.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims to have carried out 'a maior política de infraestrutura' in the country.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
33:24
About: use infrastructure projects to create formal jobs
because we carried out the largest number of infrastructure works this country has ever known. We generated a lot of jobs, many, many formal jobs,
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence states that infrastructure generated many formal jobs during his administration.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
34:10
About: appoint competent managers to carry out infrastructure projects
if there were people of Tarcísio's line at the helm, many works would be done like that.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence says he supports having people 'da linha do Tarcísio' to complete many projects.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
35:00
About: strengthen national defense capacity
Because deep down he knows that I was the president who invested the most in this country, more... and furthermore, I was the one who most took care of the armed forces. The Air Force had no planes, no ships, the Army didn't even have...
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence claims to have invested in aeronautics, the Army, and naval vessels during his administration.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
35:21
About: appoint competent managers for the Ministry of Defense
You put incompetent people in charge of the Ministry of Defense, people with no credentials, a disgrace in charge.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence Criticizes incompetent appointments and advocates nominating people with recognized credentials.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
35:35
About: denounce and expose irregularities and corruption of the previous government
I used to do it at least twice a week, exposing the lies and untruths and the corruption of your government.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence Says he denounced lies and corruption, describing his stance without proposing new action.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
43:34
About: ensure independence between branches and respect for voters' representation
The separation and independence between the powers of the Republic is one of the Constitution's entrenched clauses.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Affirms it is an entrenched clause of the Constitution without calling for concrete action.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
43:40
About: change the STF's composition (increase number of justices or institute terms)
Even so, a series of proposals are pending in Congress that aim to change the composition of the Supreme Federal Tribunal, increasing the number of ministers or establishing terms that would end the life tenure of those members of the Supreme.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Describes proposals under consideration in the National Congress without taking a stance.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
43:57
About: assess the impact of proposals that change the STF's composition on democracy
These measures have been defended by some as a way to contain alleged abuses of the judiciary, but are also seen as threats to democracy by jurists and observers given how these practices occurred in countries like Venezuela or Hungary.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence Reports that jurists see a democratic risk, a descriptive position.
- For
Desconhecido
44:14
About: ensure independence between branches and respect for voters' representation
I would like to know if you gentlemen commit, if elected, to respect the separation of powers and its independence and to discard this type of measure.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence Question asking for an explicit commitment to rule out that kind of measure.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
45:10
About: appoint a nominee to the STF (Supreme Federal Tribunal)
And I'm proud, because it was the ministers I appointed who voted on the Stem Cell case, voted on Raposa Serra do Sol, voted on Civil Union. In other words, they were people who had a posture of dignity.
Why it was classified this way · 76% confidence Claims credit for the nominations he made to the STF (Supreme Federal Tribunal).
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
45:28
About: preserve the independence of the STF and choose ministers by competence
to place a comrade, to place a party member, is a backward step, it's a regression that the Brazilian Republic already knows.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence States explicitly 'sou contra' tampering with the STF (Supreme Federal Tribunal) to favor friends.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
45:36
About: discuss in a new constituent assembly creating terms for STF ministers
it knows very well, and I am against it. I think we can discuss the future if there is a new constituent assembly, maybe to have terms or not, maybe people would have greater limitations.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence Proposes discussing terms in a new constituent assembly without a clear decision.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
45:47
About: appoint a nominee to the STF (Supreme Federal Tribunal)
But I think the Supreme Court has to be chosen by competence, by credentials and not by friendship.
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence Advocates choosing based on competence and criticizes appointments made out of friendship.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
46:05
About: present a constitutional amendment proposal to change the STF's composition
The proposed amendment to the Constitution currently being processed in the Chamber of Deputies?
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence States a proposal is under consideration without taking a position.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
46:27
About: increase the number of seats on the STF
tried to create four more vacancies for the Supreme Federal Tribunal.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence Reports a past attempt to create additional vacancies on the STF (Supreme Federal Tribunal).
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
46:49
About: nominate ministers with a legalist profile to the STF
If I happen to be re-elected, I have two more.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence States an intention to nominate more ministers if re-elected.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
48:35
About: support the privatization of Petrobras
Privatization. President Jair Bolsonaro recently advocated, on pricing, the privatization of Petrobras. I wanted to know if you continue to defend it, what would be the pricing policy and in the case of President Lula as well, ex-president Lula, what would your policy be with Petrobras and also the pricing policy regarding fuels. Good evening.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence Journalistic question asking whether the candidate still supports privatization.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
49:34
About: reduce taxes on fuels
And I, as President of the Republic, give up all federal taxes.
Why it was classified this way · 82% confidence Claims to have 'aberto mão de todos os impostos federais' as a government action.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
49:58
About: reduce prices of the basic food basket
According to Abras, from last month to now, basic supermarket basket items fell by an average of 20%.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence Cites Abras data about an average drop in prices without proposing new action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
50:44
About: install refineries and process resources domestically in Brazil
This country today refines only 80% of the gasoline it uses.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence Reports the current refining percentage without presenting a concrete proposal.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
51:06
About: assess the impacts of Petrobras privatization on fuel imports and prices
Then BR was sold, that is, BR was sold and today we have 392 companies importing gasoline from the United States without paying taxes and with dollar-denominated prices.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence Lists consequences of privatization, in a descriptive and critical tone.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
51:20
About: de-dollarize the pricing of fuels
Well, in fact, the price doesn't have to be dollarized because we carry out exploration in reais, we pay people's wages in reais and we used to build our own platforms and the rig here, things we no longer do.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Says the price should not be dollarized, advocating change.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
51:38
About: privatize Petrobras
I think privatizing Petrobras is madness; his government just privatized the gas pipelines and today we pay 3 billion reais per year in pipeline rent to use the pipelines. That is, in 10 years the money they got has already been consumed and even so we will continue paying 3 billion. I, honestly, think.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence Criticizes privatizations and cites the cost of leasing pipelines.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
52:44
About: propose a law to hold authorities who spread factually false information that harms public well-being accountable
Do you commit to proposing a specific law
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Asks whether candidates commit to proposing this law (journalistic phrasing).
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
54:20
About: combat the spread of lies and defamation in electoral campaigns
I think the campaign has to be regulated, the justice system must make decisions and every time there is a lie, we will file a lawsuit to remove
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence Proposes regulating campaigns and filing lawsuits against lies.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
56:32
About: buy legislative support from the Centrão
The Lula government bought the Centrão's support.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence A factual statement accusing the government of buying support; reports without proposing action.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
56:37
About: buy legislative support from the Centrão
The Bolsonaro government bought the Centrão's support.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence States that the other government also bought support; a factual report.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
56:45
About: engage with the National Congress without buying legislative support
Whoever is elected on October 30 will have to relate to Congress. There are many reforms to approve. What will you do?
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence Asks how to govern without buying support; describes the problem and asks for a proposal.
- For
Desconhecido
56:52
About: engage with the National Congress without buying legislative support
so that this relationship occurs without the need to buy legislative support.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence Explicitly argues that governing should occur without buying legislative support.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
57:11
About: use the secret budget to buy legislative support
Let's suppose you were a deputy. If you ever received funds from the secret budget, you will vote with me.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence Claims that those who received funds would vote with him, defending the practice.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
58:28
About: buy votes
Although I've never bought votes from little black guys.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence Denies having bought votes — a claim of innocence, without proposing action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
59:17
About: implement a federal participatory budget
Regarding the secret budget, I will try to create a participatory budget, which was something we created in the Brazilian states. Everyone remembers that the success of the participatory budget in PT city halls was such that the UN asked us, you know, to go out into the world to publicize the participatory budget. Now, with the internet, we will try to make a participatory budget. We will take the budget—the next year's budget is already ready, I will win the elections, I will take office, the budget is in place, I don't know if I will change the budget or not, but we will take the budget and send it to the people for their opinion to know what they effectively want to be done, to see if we can reduce the hold that the Centrão put on President Bolsonaro.
Why it was classified this way · 92% confidence Clearly proposes 'vou tentar criar um orçamento participativo'.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
68:29
About: recover the post-pandemic educational deficit
What concrete measures, should you be elected, will you take to recover this educational gap?
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Asks what will be done to recover learning loss — frames the issue.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
68:50
About: coordinate federal government actions with states and municipalities to recover learning
The first meeting I want to hold, in the first week of January, is with the elected governors of the 27 states.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence Proposes bringing together governors and mayors to discuss school recovery.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
69:12
About: coordinate federal government actions with states and municipalities to recover learning
the aid of a computer or internet to be able to study, that is, 2 million children are further behind than the richer ones and we need to recover. And the federal government, through the Ministry of Education, will share.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence Says MEC will share responsibility for recovery.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
69:36
About: implement catch-up campaigns and remedial classes to reduce learning gaps
We will have to do a real mobilization, call on teachers, perhaps work on Sundays, perhaps on Saturdays, so that these kids can learn what they failed to learn during the pandemic.
Why it was classified this way · 95% confidence Explicitly proposes 'fazer um verdadeiro mutirão', holding classes on Saturdays and Sundays.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
70:34
About: resume classes
The kids stayed home for two years. I was against that.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence Says 'Eu fui contra isso' referring to keeping students at home.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
71:29
About: implement technical FIES for vocational training in secondary education
We are now going to start with the technical Fies, for the kids
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence Announces 'Nós vamos começar agora com o Fies técnico' — a clear proposal.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
72:14
About: clarify and respond regarding the 'Petrolão' scheme
Lula, you didn't answer Josias de Souza's question about the 'petrolão'.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence Demands a response about the 'Petrolão' — calls for clarification, without proposing a new policy.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
72:19
About: combat corruption in refining projects and public investments
Petrolão was the biggest corruption scheme in the history of humanity.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence States it was the largest corruption scheme — describes the severity.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
73:37
About: invest in deepwater oil exploration
And we managed to extract it, and today the barrel of oil brought to land is almost the same price as a barrel of oil from Saudi Arabia.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence Claims his government achieved exploration at 7,000 meters, praising the action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
73:45
About: capitalize Petrobras to strengthen the company
The second thing is that I did Petrobras' capitalization of 70 billion, it was the largest capitalization in the history of capitalism in December 2010 and I turned Petrobras into the second largest energy company in the world.
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence claims 'eu fiz a capitalização de 70 bilhões' as a government action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
74:15
About: install refineries and process resources domestically in Brazil
We decided to build the refinery in Maranhão, a refinery in Ceará, we built the kerosene refinery, you know, in Rio Grande do Norte.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence states decisions to build refineries as an implemented policy.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
74:35
About: investigate and punish corruption at Petrobras
And if there was corruption in Petrobras, look, they arrested the thief who stole, that's it.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence asserts that corrupt people were arrested in his government, claiming action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
74:45
About: maintain transparent, corruption-free public administration
Because in our government nothing was hidden, we had no secrecy.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence claims the creation of the transparency portal and access-to-information laws.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
75:16
About: punish corrupt individuals without bankrupting companies, preserving jobs
The concrete fact is the following: if there was corruption in Petrobras, there was no need to bankrupt the companies as they were bankrupted. You should have arrested those who stole and kept the companies working because 4 million and 4 thousand jobs were lost overnight. 4 million and 400 thousand jobs and, besides that, 270 billion that ceased to be collected,
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence proposes jailing the guilty while keeping companies operating to preserve jobs.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
76:03
About: maintain transparent, corruption-free public administration
the secretive way you put so many things in your life. Everything is a reason for secrecy, everything is a reason for secrecy, everything is a reason for secrecy. You know this has short legs because it will end.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence promises to expose secrecy and states that hiding indicates a problem.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
77:04
About: strengthen defense capacity to guarantee Brazilian sovereignty
Because you know I took care of the army, when I arrived there wasn't even combat boots, the soldier was released at 11 o'clock because there wasn't money for the rations, you know the navy hardly had any ships left, you know the Air Force didn't have planes and you know I took care of the Armed Forces with care, just like you.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence claims in the first person to have 'cuidado' and modernized the Armed Forces.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
77:25
About: strengthen defense capacity to guarantee Brazilian sovereignty
You took care of the Armed Forces like I did, because I want an Armed Force prepared.
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence says 'eu quero uma Força da Armada preparada' expressing clear support.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
77:30
About: strengthen defense capacity to guarantee Brazilian sovereignty
competently armed to defend Brazilian sovereignty against possible external enemies.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence explicitly defends 'competentemente armada para defender a soberania'.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
77:42
About: appoint competent people to positions in the Armed Forces
Lula, if you respected the Armed Forces, you would put competent people to serve as my defense, and not comrades up there.
Why it was classified this way · 72% confidence proposes 'botaria gente competente' for defense positions.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
77:53
About: complete the refineries that were started
You started building three refineries, you didn't finish any.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence criticizes the non-completion of refineries, implying support for finishing them.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
77:56
About: maintain national control over the refineries
You bought a little refinery abroad, a scrap. You handed over two of our refineries to Evo Morales of Bolivia.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence accuses handing refineries over to foreign parties and advocates keeping national control.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
78:33
About: revitalize Itaboraí's economy
Itaburaí became a ghost town there in Rio de Janeiro.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence claims that Itaboraí 'virou uma cidade fantasma' — a description of the problem.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
78:49
About: investigate illegal transfers of funds abroad
One billion went to the United States, to the stock exchange, which was harmed by the interference in prices.
Why it was classified this way · 62% confidence reports transfer of funds abroad as an effect of irregularities.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
78:55
About: investigate corruption at Petrobras
Look here, Lula, the companies that stole from Petrobrás.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence lists companies involved and accuses theft at Petrobras, a factual account.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
79:00
About: recover funds diverted by corruption
Odebrecht returned 2.7 billion, SBM 1.3, Andrade Gutierrez 1.4, Braskem 2.8 billion.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence lists amounts returned by companies — a description of restitution.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
79:18
About: recover funds diverted by corruption
16 billion reais that the companies returned, added to 6 billion from the cooperating witnesses.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence adds up returned amounts as factual information about the cases.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
79:32
About: investigate and punish those involved in corruption at Petrobras
These thieves returned 30 billion reais, excluding what wasn't found. You come and say there was no theft, that you worked for the good of Petrobrás; it's not even worth debating. I didn't say there was no theft, because people
Why it was classified this way · 72% confidence claims there was theft and that funds were recovered — a critical report.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
79:50
About: punish confessed corruption crimes
When a guy confesses the crime, it's because he committed a crime.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence states 'quando o cara confessa o crime' as a descriptive assertion.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
79:53
About: hold accountable and punish those who disobey the law
People went there and reported that there was theft at Petrobrás; it may have happened. What I mean is that to fight corruption, you didn't need to ruin the companies.
Why it was classified this way · 86% confidence advocates punishing owners without closing companies, citing international examples.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
80:03
About: hold accountable and punish those who disobey the law
you didn't need to close the companies. In Korea they didn't shut down Samsung, in Germany they didn't shut down Volkswagen, in France they didn't shut down Alstom; that is, they arrested the company owner and the workers kept working, the company kept producing and things happened. You know that the Paulo Petrochini of Itaboraí was 85% ready.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence uses examples (Samsung, Volkswagen) to argue against closing companies.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
80:36
About: maintain public control of the Itaboraí petrochemical complex
because many allegations were raised, not half of the allegations were proven and there is Paulo Petroquim rusting away, perhaps, to be privatized for peanuts, as was done with the
Why it was classified this way · 72% confidence criticizes a possible privatization 'a troco de banana' and defends keeping it public.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
81:04
About: avoid political appointments to state-owned company leadership
You held an auction in exchange for support inside the parliament. No, no, don't lie. You put... Don't lie, it's ugly. People appointed... Jato Lula,
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence reiterates an accusation of trading support for partisan appointments.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
81:14
About: avoid political appointments to state-owned company leadership
With party groups. People came in to plunder. And you, with the votes coming in to approve your proposals inside, you reveled.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence says that party groups entered 'para saquear' state-owned companies.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
81:34
About: prioritize infrastructure investment in Brazil
You handed over 1 billion and 60 million dollars to your friend Chávez and Maduro; they built the metro there abroad, left Brazil high and dry and there's no metro here in Brazil. And
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence criticizes sending funds abroad instead of investing domestically.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
81:56
About: hold accountable and punish those who disobey the law
the Lava Jato prosecutors, the judges — the responsibility for corruption in Brazil was yours, the numbers are there.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence assigns responsibility for corruption and thus supports accountability.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
82:21
About: clarify partisan influences in Petrobras appointments
In fact, one of his chiefs at the Civil House is from the party that provided the director of Petrobrás.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence points to a party link of the Chief of Staff connected to Petrobras.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
82:30
About: avoid political appointments to state-owned company leadership
It wasn't one day, it was 33 years at Petrobrás. He was appointed for his competence.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence defends that the director was 'indicado por competência'.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
82:42
About: avoid political appointments to state-owned company leadership
So, what's important to say clearly is the following: the people who were appointed to Petrobrás were appointed by the Board, because you know that you appoint the director of Petrobrás to the Board of Petrobrás, and Petrobrás is the one that appoints the Board.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence explains the nomination process to the Board and Petrobras governance.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
83:02
About: raise the minimum wage above inflation according to the new fiscal rule
you would explain why it's been four years since you haven't given a real increase to the minimum wage.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence demands an explanation for four years without a real increase to the minimum wage.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
83:09
About: raise the minimum wage above inflation according to the new fiscal rule
There are 36 million retirees, 36 million who earn the minimum wage, of which 22 million retirees have gone four years without receiving a real increase.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence presents figures on retirees and beneficiaries without proposing immediate action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
83:22
About: raise the minimum wage above inflation according to the new fiscal rule
In my government, they received a 74% real increase.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence claims as an achievement of their government ('receberam 74% de aumento real').
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
83:26
About: increase economic growth
That's why the economy grew. Do you know how much the economy grew in my government? It grew on average 4%. Do you know how much it's growing in yours? Less than 2%.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence compares past and present growth rates without detailing actions.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
83:46
About: revitalize the Brazilian automotive industry
When I left the presidency, the auto industry produced 3.7 million cars.
Why it was classified this way · 60% confidence reports automobile production before and after — descriptive data.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
86:09
About: reduce poverty
A government that lifted 36 million people out of absolute poverty.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence claims lifting 36 million out of poverty as an achievement of their government.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
86:14
About: expand access to vocational education and higher education
A government that brought 42 million Brazilians to a middle-class standard of consumption. The government that built the most universities in Brazil's history. The government that enrolled the most young people. We took Brazil with 3.5 million young people in university and left it with 8 million young people in university. Brazil had 140 technical schools; we built 422 technical schools. In other words, we improved because we had the best Minister of Education in Brazil, who was comrade Fernando Haddad.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence claims an increase in the number of young people and technical schools during their government.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
86:47
About: increase funding for municipal education
the best Minister of Education, who created Fundeb. The education budget rose 160% under our government.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence states that the education budget rose 160% during their government.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
86:55
About: value teaching activity and avoid its mechanization
We created the teachers' minimum salary because this country was taking a leap in quality. Brazil was the 12th largest economy in the world, it reached 6th.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence cites the creation of a minimum salary for teachers as a defended policy.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
87:24
About: reduce fires and deforestation in the Amazon
The best record on Amazon deforestation was under our government.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence claims to have achieved 'o melhor desmatamento' in their government — a defense of policy.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
87:31
About: reduce fires and deforestation in the Amazon
And yours is the worst every year.
Why it was classified this way · 82% confidence criticizes the current government for increased deforestation and calls for reduction.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
87:34
About: reduce fires and deforestation in the Amazon
You are playing at deforesting, you are playing at opening fences, you are playing at tearing things down, you'll see what will happen to Brazilian trade.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence condemns deforestation actions and warns of consequences for Brazilian trade.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
87:43
About: promote sustainable agribusiness practices and protect the Amazon
Because the Brazilian agribusiness person who is serious, who wants to make money, who wants to export, knows that they cannot invade the Amazon.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence says that serious agribusiness does not invade the Amazon, advocating sustainable practices.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
88:00
About: combat invasions of indigenous lands and illegal mining
there to be invasions of indigenous land, illegal mining, and much less anyone wanting to plant corn, soy or...
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence explicitly declares 'não permitir... invasão em terra indígena, em garimpo ilegal'.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
88:07
About: restore degraded lands for agricultural use
some other crop in places where it shouldn't be planted. We have 30 million alquejas of degraded land that can be recovered to plant whatever you want in the country.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence proposes using 30 million degraded alqueires for planting, as an alternative to deforestation.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
90:02
About: promote low-carbon agriculture to attract international funds
because we will make low-carbon agriculture enable Brazil to receive
Why it was classified this way · 86% confidence declares 'vamos fazer com que a agricultura de baixo carbono' attract resources.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
90:14
About: attract international resources for environmental services and carbon sequestration while preserving the Amazon
from the European Union and other countries because of the sequestration of gases and titufas that we will implement by preserving the Amazon, something you don't know. We will try to make the Amazon's biodiversity a way to enrich the people of the Amazon, nearly 30 million people who live there, and not deforest and not dismantle as you are doing.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence proposes revenue from gas sequestration and preservation of the Amazon.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
90:43
About: create the Ministry of Indigenous Peoples with an indigenous-appointed minister
When will we ban it? Our government will not allow it. In fact, I'll give you a piece of news. I will create the Ministry of Indigenous Peoples.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence explicitly announces the creation of the ministry and an indigenous appointment.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
91:09
About: safeguard Brazil's ability to regulate environmental protection and conserve natural resources
to divide the Amazon's biodiversity with the world.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence responds to the accusation of 'dividir a biodiversidade' by defending national sovereignty.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
91:32
About: guarantee freedom of expression
You say all the time that you want to control the media, that you'll control the media.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence accuses an intention to 'controlar a mídia' and thus supports freedom of the press.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
92:50
About: reduce tariffs and restore trade relations between countries
No country invites you to go there and no one wants to come here, because I'm going to vote to open this country to the world.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence declares the intention to 'abrir esse país para o mundo' as foreign policy.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
92:56
About: enter into international agreements for research and sustainable use of Amazon biodiversity
What we are going to do is do an Amazônia plan, we are going to make agreements to research the wealth of the Amazon's biodiversity for the benefit of the Brazilian people and for the benefit of humanity.
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence proposes agreements to research the wealth of biodiversity for national benefit.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
93:22
About: appoint ministers who protect the Amazon and curb deforestation
You sincerely know that you put in a minister who was clearing everything and said it was to open the land, it was to let the herd in.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence criticizes the appointment of a minister who encouraged deforestation, advocating protective appointments.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
93:51
About: guarantee security of rural property and prevent invasions
Those who invade are breaking the law and that will end, that will end.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence states that invasions 'vai acabar', promising action against transgressions.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
94:43
About: question the opponent's international alliances
Ortega is your friend, isn't he? I'll speak.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence directs a question about Ortega as Lula's ally, aiming to politicize ties.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
94:45
About: question the opponent's international alliances
Is Ortega your friend? I'll speak. Is Ortega your friend? Ask the question. Yes, he greeted you when you went to the second round here. Ask the question. There he...
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence repeats and insists on linking Lula to Ortega, signaling an attack on alliances.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
95:10
About: guarantee religious freedom
He banned processions, closed the country, a disrespect to religions.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence says processions were prohibited and there was disrespect for religions, an explicit criticism.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
95:26
About: offer asylum to persecuted religious and humanitarian persons
When I said at the UN that I had open doors to receive peace nuns.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence says he was 'de portas abertas' to receive nuns, proposing a humanitarian policy.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
95:38
About: decriminalize drugs
And asked for the decriminalization of marijuana, or rather, of cocaine, which is even more serious.
Why it was classified this way · 92% confidence attributes to Petro a request for decriminalization and frames it as a negative accusation.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
95:47
About: carry out police operations to combat trafficking and robberies
These are your friends here in Brazil, they are the bosses of the community. It's not the people from Complexo do Alemão, no. The people there are decent, law-abiding, hardworking. You are friends with the minority, people from CPX and the traffickers. And now you're also friends with Ortega and Petro, who call for the decriminalization of cocaine and who arrest priests and nuns. Is that right, Lula? Talk about your friend here.
Why it was classified this way · 86% confidence associates the opponent with traffickers and criticizes that relationship, advocating the fight against crime.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
96:25
About: maintain relations with leftist movements and governments
to take part in the celebration of the anniversary of the Sandinista Revolution.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence states having participated in the celebration, claiming a historical connection.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
96:29
About: recognize struggles against dictatorships
that overthrew a dictator called Somoza of 30 years.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence reports a historical fact about the overthrow of Somoza without proposing explicit action.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
96:34
About: respect presidential term limits
Now, the political regime of Nicaragua is something that depends on them, and Daniel Ortega knows, you know, Chaves knows, everyone knows.
Why it was classified this way · 65% confidence says the regime depends on Nicaraguans; a descriptive comment about sovereignty.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
96:42
About: respect presidential term limits
that if I had wanted to believe in a perpetual mandate, I would have accepted the third term when they offered it to me.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence denies seeking perpetual mandate and defends not accepting continuous terms.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
96:48
About: respect presidential term limits
I think that whoever believes they are indispensable, irreplaceable, begins to become a dictator.
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence states that those who see themselves as indispensable tend to become dictators, opposing perpetual mandates.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
96:54
About: international sanctions for violations
So, if Daniel Ortega is wronging the people of Nicaragua, let Daniel Ortega be punished. If Maduro is wronging the people, let him be punished.
Why it was classified this way · 86% confidence says 'que puna o Daniel Ortega' and 'que puna o Maduro', calling for them to be held accountable.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
97:05
About: return to government
July 30, October 30, get ready.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence announces dates and expresses conviction that the people will return him to government, an explicit promise.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
97:20
About: implement social protection policies for workers and women
because the people need someone to take care of them.
Why it was classified this way · 82% confidence says the people need someone to take care of them, supporting social policies.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
97:35
About: increase the value of the social benefit (Auxílio Brasil/Bolsa Família)
The one who takes care of the people is me, of the poorest.
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence says 'Quem cuida do povo sou eu' and highlights Auxílio Brasil as his work.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
97:43
About: increase the value of the social benefit (Auxílio Brasil/Bolsa Família)
I tripled the average value of Bolsa Família.
Why it was classified this way · 92% confidence declares having tripled the average value of Bolsa Família — a claim of achievement.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
98:08
About: carry out police operations to combat trafficking and robberies
It's not the working people, it's the traffickers.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence claims the opponent's allies are traffickers, advocating combating crime.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
98:36
About: avoid adopting political-economic models that led countries into crisis
Venezuela, Lula campaigned for Chávez back then and for Maduro as well.
Why it was classified this way · 82% confidence recalls campaigning for Chávez/Maduro and warns about the country's direction, urging to avoid that model.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
98:48
About: avoid economic policies that cause recession
Look at how the people of Venezuela are, the country richest in the world in oil, whose people live in a poverty below
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence uses the Venezuelan situation as a warning not to follow the same economic model.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
99:30
About: change the economic equation to reduce poverty and privileges
Is this what we want for Brazil?
Why it was classified this way · 83% confidence asks rhetorically if this is the model desired for Brazil, opposing it.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
101:03
About: increase the value of the social benefit (Auxílio Brasil/Bolsa Família)
If you were so worried about the poor, as you say you are, Lula, why did Bolsa Família start at 42 reais per month for a family?
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence asks why Bolsa Família started at R$42, criticizing the history and arguing for a higher amount.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
102:50
About: combat corruption in refining projects and public investments
A country governed by thieves — that's what Gilmar Mendes said.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence says 'um país governado por ladrões' and cites Gilmar Mendes, accusing and calling for action.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
103:14
About: prevent people accused of corruption from returning to power
And not wanting to return to the scene of the crime. Lula!
Why it was classified this way · 86% confidence asks Lula to 'fique em casa' and not return to the 'cena do crime', an anti-return stance.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
107:03
About: guarantee religious freedom
the guy who has the most nerve to tell the truth here. First, the one who approved the 2003 law on religious freedom was
Why it was classified this way · 86% confidence claims to have passed a law on religious freedom in 2003 and defends that policy.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
107:15
About: preserve institutions' independence and strengthen confidence in them
I am the one who defends democracy and freedom.
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence asserts he defends democracy and freedom and claims that stance.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
107:18
About: preserve the Judiciary's independence and prevent politicization
Much more than him, who is a little petty dictator, who wants to occupy the Supreme Court.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence accuses the opponent of wanting to 'ocupar a Suprema Corte' and positions himself against it.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
107:33
About: reduce hunger
I want to govern this country democratically, as I have already governed twice, giving priority to the problems of the Brazilian people, prioritizing taking care of the people, because there are 33 million people going hungry.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence proposes prioritizing the people's problems and cites 33 million going hungry as justification.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
116:58
About: increase workers' purchasing power
When he spoke about public universities and technical schools, when he spoke about generation of jobs and income, when he spoke about the real increase of the minimum wage, which people remember and know happened during Lula's government and regressed under Bolsonaro's government.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence refers to the real minimum wage increase under Lula's government as a historical fact.
- For
Desconhecido
117:12
About: implement public health measures to control the Covid-19 pandemic
So, bringing up the economic issue of people's real lives, recalling what the tragedy of the pandemic was, Bolsonaro's criminal responsibility in that, I think it was very important.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence attributes criminal responsibility to Bolsonaro for the pandemic and defends raising the issue in the debate.
- For
Desconhecido
117:41
About: prioritize employment and income policies
People want to know if there will be food on the table, if there will be jobs, if the economy will improve.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence says people want jobs and that Lula responded well to that demand.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
119:57
About: maintain transparent, corruption-free public administration
The problem is that Bolsonaro keeps lying the same things, the same thing. It's Venezuela, it's Nicaragua, it's the Unicex bathroom, that is, everyone knows it's a lie, but he keeps stating it as if it were something that is part of his political culture.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence accuses Bolsonaro of lying and complains he doesn't answer questions about the minimum wage and education.
Luis Inacio Lula da Silva
120:28
About: increase workers' purchasing power
But I think the people have already found out.
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence says they asked twice about the minimum wage and defends speaking up for the poor.
- For
Desconhecido
122:48
About: guarantee right of reply for journalists in electoral debates
that the journalist has no right of reply, the rules are like that, and the committees insist a lot on this point, the committees of both campaigns, so you ask the question, the boss answers, you ask A, the boss answers Z, and you cannot retort.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence complains that journalists don't have the right of reply and that this undermines accountability.
- For
Desconhecido
123:52
About: hold accountable and punish those who disobey the law
Valdemar Costa Neto was arrested in Mensalão, he is the president of the party for which Bolsonaro is running. The president of the PL. So they completely dodged the questions and it wasn't just that, the others too, there was an important question about the STF, whether they committed to not tampering
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence lists names and accuses corrupt practices at Petrobras, demanding investigation.
- For
Desconhecido
124:28
About: ensure the Judiciary's independence and impartiality
with its composition.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence reports asking for a commitment not to touch the STF (Supreme Federal Tribunal) and criticizes candidates' evasiveness.
Jair Messias Bolsonaro
126:53
About: transfer crime leaders to federal maximum-security prisons
Look, about the debate, it was clear that the former president Lula, unfortunately, did not manage to answer important questions that are necessary to clarify for the Brazilian population. One of them there, why did the PT...
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence accuses Lula of never transferring PCC leaders and questions the use of federal prisons.
- For
Desconhecido
127:58
About: investigate and hold accountable those responsible for corruption at Petrobras
Who appointed the directors of Petrobras? Paulo Roberto Costa, Nestor Severo, Renato Duque, who are at the core
Why it was classified this way · 90% confidence accuses Lula of appointing directors involved in corruption and calls for accountability.
- For
Desconhecido
129:22
About: remove PT from power
We are back here with Josias. Now President Jair Bolsonaro spoke, he was questioned about the participation of the former judge Sérgio Moura, now elected senator for Paraná, in the debate. Clearly Moura gave Bolsonaro coaching to make the questions about corruption, to approach the subject. And Moura was saying now that he has more convergences than divergences with Bolsonaro and said that Lula did not answer certain questions. I was talking with Josias first here. Josias, regarding the level of aggressiveness that was expected of the debate, it ultimately did not happen.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence explicitly declares opposition to Lula and to the PT's return to government.
- For
Desconhecido
130:52
About: implement public health measures to control the Covid-19 pandemic
He dominated the scene, he brought the debate into the real world, he managed to exploit Bolsonaro's main weak point, which is the management of the pandemic. He was very good in the first debate, without a doubt; it gave the impression, in the first block, very much so, that he was going to dominate the debate, but he lost his way in the debate.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence praises Lula for exploiting pandemic management as Bolsonaro's weak point.
- For
Desconhecido
131:33
About: distance Brazil from authoritarian regimes
Lula didn't handle the corruption issue properly, he didn't handle it adequately and he also didn't handle well the issue Bolsonaro heavily exploits, the PT's relationship with the Latin American dictatorships. And I don't understand why Lula does that. What's the need for him to attach himself to Nicaragua? Why can't he disentangle himself from that? Can't he give a categorical answer regarding Nicaragua? So he allows Bolsonaro to swim freely on that subject. So I would venture to say...
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence questions why Lula is tied to Nicaragua and demands a categorical answer on the issue.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
134:20
About: measure government approval via opinion polls
All of this we're saying here, sometimes we have one impression watching the debate and the public has a completely different impression. But by the rhythm we were checking in the polls, if you take December of last year, the Bolsonaro government had an over 50% bad or very bad rating.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence Reports results of a historical survey without proposing explicit action.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
136:19
About: reduce hunger
Going hungry, very high inflation, unemployment, families have been impoverished, this reality.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Lists hunger as a social problem without advocating a specific policy in the speech.
- For
Desconhecido
136:28
About: reduce fires and deforestation in the Amazon
So, I think it was important and showed well that, look, when I was president, we had 20 million workers with formal contracts, Brazil advanced more, Brazil in the environmental issue, today there is deforestation in the Amazon by land grabbers, miners, totally irresponsible. So I think it was positive always to clarify the electorate.
Why it was classified this way · 82% confidence Criticizes current deforestation and compares it to past advances of his government.
- Against
Desconhecido
138:32
About: avoid using family and gender topics as a campaign tactic
gender in school, the family theme, the culture war.
Why it was classified this way · 82% confidence Criticizes Bolsonaro's use of these topics as a campaign strategy.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
138:37
About: apply content removal decisions on social networks
And the issue of Bolsonaro's phrase, that a vibe arose between him and the Venezuelan girls, addressed tangentially by Lula, Bolsonaro uses Alexandre de Moraes' ruling, president of the TSE, which orders the PT to remove that from the networks. Lula was wearing a pin, which is a daisy from the Faça Bonito campaign, which is a campaign to protect young people, children and adolescents from sexual exploitation. Folks, Lula was trying to send an indirect message with that pin he was wearing, but very subliminally there, that's what didn't work.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence Reports a decision by Minister Alexandre de Moraes that ordered content removal.
- Against
Desconhecido
140:06
About: avoid associating candidates with organized crime without evidence
for the campaigns, those watching us here, they'll obviously take both Lula's campaign and Bolsonaro's campaign, take clips of both participants and edit them, put them on television, distribute them in WhatsApp groups, post them on social media, that's very important. Bolsonaro will have abundant material to edit freely, because he spoke uninterrupted for a long time. These are associations that I consider very strong, the association of Lula with organized crime, I thought it was a heavy association. It's a
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence Calls the association between Lula and organized crime a 'mentira'.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
140:57
About: investigate corruption in Petrobras while preserving the company
Lula tried to use a formula there he used on Jornal Nacional, used in other debates, used in interviews of saying, no, you can't break the company, you have to investigate the corruption, but you can't break the company. But there was a time I admitted, no, yes, there was theft. I think he had a phrase to that effect, that I don't remember seeing Lula speak with such clarity.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Reports that Lula advocated investigating corruption without 'quebrar a empresa'.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
143:23
About: commit to adopting stricter rules against disinformation
But the answers came with the candidates wanting to play in their own field, in their own turf, or push the wear onto the other, or avoid taking commitments. Patrícia Campos Mello's question was a question of commitment. Do you commit to being stricter? Yes or no?
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence Notes that the question about commitment to be tougher was not answered.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
150:46
About: create or strengthen a ministry for indigenous affairs
I think it's not something that will make much difference to the voter. The news is out there. I think everyone knows about it, but it's not something on either one's government plan. I think overall we also had some interesting things, I think Lula brought this news about the Ministry, about the indigenous people he mentioned, but overall I think the debate ended up being very useful for the voter.
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence Reports that Lula brought news about an indigenous ministry, without directly endorsing it.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
153:16
About: value and publicize reports by people who warned about corruption
Yeah, it ended up being... it was even, as we say down South, it was an even debate. But I think Bolsonaro comes out ahead on some points because he didn't lose his composure, because of the seven minutes. And I also think he knew how to question very well the petrolão issue, corruption in Lula's government. He kept that the whole time, Lula on the defensive. Yeah, he kept repeating, "you lie, you lie," that gets into people's heads. What we talk about so much at UOL is
Why it was classified this way · 72% confidence Describes that Bolsonaro questioned the petrolão, without explicitly proposing action.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
153:41
About: use a symbolic and repetitive strategy in the campaign
symbolic, which takes the cognitive shortcuts of people and people go, lie, lie. So this ended up being a strategy, even if he didn't do media training, it ended up being a positive strategy, right? And Lula losing his speech, his voice there was complicated for him. The
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence 'Simbólico' and 'atalhos cognitivos' describe a strategy, without explicit endorsement.
- For
Desconhecido
154:10
About: answer journalists' questions in the debate
They didn't answer; if they had answered, maybe it would have been the best part, the most constructive part of the debate, but they didn't answer, they said whatever they wanted.
Why it was classified this way · 88% confidence Says that if they had answered it would have been the most constructive part.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
154:42
About: maintain stability in electoral polls after debates
I believe we still won't see much change, I think the debate was...
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence States there will not be a large change in the polls after the debate.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
154:48
About: maintain stability in electoral polls after debates
it spoke to the converted, it didn't take votes nor gain votes. I think we'll still see stability in the polls.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence Reiterates that the debate 'falou para os convertidos' and should not change votes.
- For
Desconhecido
154:59
About: convince voters and regain electoral ground
it ends up being positive for him. Bolsonaro, as we were saying here, those seven minutes, Bolsonaro could have used them to speak to those undecided voters. And he didn't.
Why it was classified this way · 85% confidence Criticizes Bolsonaro for not using the seven minutes to speak to undecided voters.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
155:14
About: expand electoral appeal beyond the bubble
but even if he had stayed calm, he only showed that, okay, he can hold a debate, but he doesn't get out of his bubble, he can't. For 30 years he hasn't been able to, right?
Why it was classified this way · 70% confidence States that Bolsonaro 'não consegue sair' from the bubble for decades, a critical description.
- For
Desconhecido
156:03
About: limit continuous speaking time in debates to balance participation
That left Bolsonaro on the ropes, with his hands tied, on the defensive. Then, in the second block, there was a balance between the two. The journalists' questions helped and hurt one and the other. And in the third block, I think Bolsonaro devoured Lula. I didn't understand why he left those 7 minutes for Bolsonaro to speak freely. It was better for Bolsonaro than a free airtime on television. More time. Even more time, in fact. And worse, then when the...
Why it was classified this way · 82% confidence Questions why they left seven minutes, benefiting one candidate.
- For
Desconhecido
156:32
About: respond to and debate abortion and gender ideology issues in debates
the microphone came back to him, he didn't answer the questions Bolsonaro raised, which were questions of custom, the old story of abortion, the old story of gender ideology, he let all that go by.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Criticizes Lula for letting questions about abortion and gender ideology pass.
- For
Desconhecido
157:48
About: interpret social media polls with caution
Quest qualitative was only regarding social networks. It gave Bolsonaro victory by 56 to 34, if I'm not mistaken. But that's a result I think we shouldn't give much weight to, because it may simply mean that Bolsonaro's supporters participated more, participated more, as it is, in fact, a... a clash
Why it was classified this way · 86% confidence States that results from social networks should not be given much weight; an explicit argument.
- For
Desconhecido
158:11
About: avoid accusations of collusion with criminals against opponents
awake, was betting more. It may simply mean that. Now, I think the qualy is more interesting, why? It pointed out some of Bolsonaro's answers, for example, that displeased a lot the people who were listening. And one of them was when he suggested that the ex-president Lula's visit to the Complexo do Alemão was an attempt by him to get close to criminals. That landed very badly. He said that
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Says that the accusation about Lula in Alemão 'pegou muito mal', suggesting avoiding such an attack.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
158:42
About: increase real social spending
a good moment for Lula and a terrible moment for Bolsonaro in the debate. A good moment for Bolsonaro, according to this group that was being monitored, was when he spoke about increasing Auxílio Brasil.
Why it was classified this way · 72% confidence Reports that mention of the increase to Auxílio Brasil was well received by a portion of the audience.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
159:40
About: maintain stability in electoral polls after debates
Who here changed their vote? There were 20 people. Do you know how many changed their vote? None.
Why it was classified this way · 80% confidence Reports a qualitative sample of 20 undecided voters in which none changed their vote.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
159:49
About: convert debate performance into votes in polls
That's right. So, I think that's it. Bolsonaro may have performed better than former president Lula, but I think he'll have a lot of difficulty converting that performance into votes.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence Says Bolsonaro may have performed better, but will have difficulty converting that into votes.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
160:01
About: confirm victory when leading in polls through the second round
Hey Thaís, when we analyze the final stretch of the elections, we've covered several elections already, Lula is ahead. Now, it's a narrow difference. Datafolha gives 53% of the valid votes against 47%. It's not a comfortable lead. If there is a movement, it's an open election. We can put it that way. However, if we look at the history, Thaís, of elections in Brazil and of presidential candidates who entered the second round in the lead — candidates who advanced to the second round ahead — that candidate ends up confirming the victory.
Why it was classified this way · 75% confidence Points to a historical pattern that whoever leads tends to confirm victory, a historical description.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
160:56
About: consider presidential election turnarounds unlikely
Without a doubt, Kennedy. There is not, as you said, in Brazil's history, a single case of a turnaround in a presidential election. There are several cases of turnarounds in gubernatorial elections. In fact, there was also a Quest study that did this survey. So, in gubernatorial elections, there were 11 turnarounds under conditions similar to what we see now in the presidential election, with the second-placed and the first separated by up to five points.
Why it was classified this way · 78% confidence States there are no cases of comebacks in presidential elections; a historical assessment.
- Neutral
Desconhecido
161:52
About: convert debate performance into votes in polls
does this signal? It signals that it is very difficult for Bolsonaro to still turn this thing around.
Why it was classified this way · 74% confidence Concludes it is very difficult for the runner-up to overturn the presidential result.
AI classification from the transcript of a public video. See the Methodology